A week ago I posted about the debate of using plastic, wood, and glass in the Montessori classroom. Thank you so much to those of you who answered! I got my desired reaction, which was the sharing of ideas and some conversation!
Most of you were polite and productive with your comments. I had one person on Twitter say that someone who suggests using plastic in the Montessori classroom obviously does not embrace the Montessori philosophy. At first, I assumed that she was commenting in general, but then I realized that she was directing the comment to me.
I’d like to clarify a bit here.
I do tend to prefer the use of glass and ceramic in the Montessori classroom, as it is what Maria wanted. Natural consequences are that careless use of the materials leads to them breaking, and the child will then try to be more careful.
I ask the budget question, because eventually money can run out, and honestly, I don’t have a lot of extra money to keep replacing materials myself.
The stories that I shared reflected the practices of other Montessori teachers and schools out there. These practices are not strictly done at the three schools that I talked about. They are used all over the place, with similar justifications. I was using those stories as examples. And one of those schools is AMS accredited and works closely with Sister Anthonita Portia, so you know it is actually a pretty good school! At another one, I specifically worked closely with Sr. Anthonita as the school grew and progressed. And the other one has started the accreditation process a couple of times, but it is a long and arduous process.
I have another question for people regarding the use of unbreakables in the classroom. What do you do when you have a group of children who have issues that prevent them from maintaining body control? For example, the boys with Sensory Processing Disorder who cannot regulate their bodies and are still crashing into things as they make their way through the evaluation process and determining the appropriate sensory diet?
What do you choose to do when you have a class of mostly three year-olds who have never been entrusted with glass before in their lives? Their mothers still have them drinking out of sippy cups so as not to stain their carpeting and cause unnecessary cleaning?
In an ideal world, parents would be easily convinced to start using glass at home, but realistically it is difficult to convince them.
And the jury is still out on helping children with SPD in the Montessori classroom. I have had both good and bad experiences with it. I have also been in contact with the professionals, and they have also heard mixed reviews, but mostly that Montessori is not an appropriate environment.
I guess this post has kind of taken two directions all mixed into one. I wonder what Maria would do? (WWMD? haha)
I think she would like to have smaller groups of children and would work really hard with them in the beginning of the year to reinforce careful movements and handling of fragile materials. Perhaps starting with something like wood would be better, as it is still naturally beautiful, and yes wood can break when it is dropped! I’m just curious what you all think?